Barton's Pizzeria Menu (Update 2026)

At Barton's Pizzeria, we serve classic Italian-style pizza crafted with a focus on quality and simplicity. Our menu features a variety of options, including cheese, sausage, and customizable toppings to satisfy all tastes. Whether you prefer a quick takeaway or delivery straight to your door, we keep our prices affordable so everyone can enjoy a slice of Naples in Hammond, Indiana. Our weekly specials, like the large one-topping pizza with cheesy garlic breadsticks on Monday for just $22, make it easy to feed the family without breaking the bank.

Barton's Pizzeria Menu image 1
Barton's Pizzeria Menu image 2
Barton's Pizzeria Menu image 3
Barton's Pizzeria Menu image 4
Barton's Pizzeria Menu image 5
Barton's Pizzeria Menu image 6
Barton's Pizzeria Menu image 7
Barton's Pizzeria Menu image 8
Barton's Pizzeria Menu image 9
Barton's Pizzeria

Interior, Food, and Ambiance at Barton's Pizzeria

Step inside Barton's Pizzeria, and you'll find a casual, family-friendly atmosphere perfect for dinner or a quick bite. The space is quiet and unpretentious, designed to make you feel at home. Our wheelchair-accessible parking, entrance, and seating ensure convenience for all guests. Enjoy your favorite slices or sandwiches with the comfort of table service, or opt for takeout if you prefer to dine at home. Kids love our laid-back vibe, and parents appreciate the straightforward menu, making every visit a hassle-free experience.

Barton's Pizzeria

About Barton's Pizzeria Food and Specialties

Barton's Pizzeria has been a staple in the Hammond area for over 45 years. We are proud to serve recognizable, consistent flavors with a nostalgic touch. Our specialty lies in crispy crusts, rich tomato sauce, and high-quality cheese — essentials for an authentic experience. We offer gluten-free crusts and vegan cheese to accommodate dietary needs, making us a welcoming joint for everyone. From our savory Italian sausage to our famed cheese bread, we deliver comfort food that brings families and friends together. Our sausage tastes as good as it did decades ago, a true testament to our dedication to authentic recipes.

Barton's Pizzeria

At Barton's, the focus remains on delivering simple, quality food in a friendly, accessible environment. Their specialty lies in basic but flavorful pizzas and sandwiches that stand the test of time and trends. The owners envision a community hub where everyone can reliably find comfort food that evokes nostalgia. They are committed to using fresh ingredients, offering dietary options like gluten-free crusts and vegan cheese, and maintaining a welcoming atmosphere for families and individuals alike. Their goal is to keep the spirit of old-school pizza joints alive—where effort is put into flavor and service, not fuss.

Barton's continues to grow as a trusted neighborhood staple, dedicated to serving classic eats with honesty and care. Their long-term vision centers on strengthening community ties, maintaining affordability, and providing quick, satisfying meals that feel like a hug from an old friend.